Interdisciplinary Debate
Participants are challenged to defend a disciplinary perspective that is not their own. This exercise encourages critical thinking and helps students learn to evaluate arguments effectively.
Cómo ejecutarlo
- 1
Present the statements based on the literature the participants have read.
- 2
Divide participants into two groups: one supporting the statement and the other opposing it. Ideally, assign students to groups contrary to their usual viewpoints. Select about five participants to serve as the jury.
- 3
Allow time for each group to prepare their arguments and discuss their viewpoints on the literature. Each group should formulate as many supporting arguments as possible and anticipate counterarguments.
- 4
Instruct the jury to focus on the rhetorical structure of both groups' arguments, prior to the debate, identifying different types of arguments from the readings. They should also prepare a brief summary of the articles' conclusions to introduce the debate.
- 5
Kick off the debate, managing time effectively throughout.
- 6
During the debate, the jury analyzes the nature of the arguments and decides on a winner.
Consejos
Encourage participants to truly step into the shoes of the perspective they are defending for a deeper understanding.
Remind the jury to remain objective and focus on evaluating the arguments rather than expressing personal opinions.
Facilitate a debriefing session after the debate to discuss insights and reflections.
Variaciones
You can adapt the method by including a written component where students submit their arguments in advance. This allows for deeper reflection.
Casos de uso
Métodos relacionados
Planifica tu próximo taller con IA
Workshop Weaver te ayuda a combinar métodos como Interdisciplinary Debate en una agenda completa y cronometrada en minutos.
Probar gratisMethod descriptions on Workshop Weaver are original content written by our team, based on established facilitation practices. This method was inspired by work from SessionLab. Licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.