3-2-1 Bridge
3-2-1 Bridge is a before-and-after reflection routine in which participants record their first take on a topic as three thoughts, two questions and one metaphor, repeat the same after a learning experience, and then describe how the two sets relate. It is one of the thinking routines developed by Project Zero at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and described in the book Making Thinking Visible (Ritchhart, Church and Morrison, 2011). The final 'bridge' step makes the change in understanding explicit instead of leaving it unnoticed.
Déroulé d'animation
- 1
Name the topic in one sentence and ask for three thoughts, two questions and one metaphor or simile, written individually.
4 min - 2
After the learning experience: everyone writes a second set of three thoughts, two questions and one metaphor or simile.
4 min - 3
Bridge in pairs: each person explains how the second set connects to or departs from the first, and what caused the shift.
6 min - 4
Collect a few bridges in plenary and capture the open questions that remain.
4 min
Conseils
Say at the start that first responses are a starting point and cannot be wrong, otherwise people write what they think you want to see.
Keep the first round quick, two to three minutes, so that it captures gut associations.
Give an example of a metaphor on an unrelated topic, because that part is where people most often get stuck.
Spend the larger share of the time on the bridge, which is where the routine does its work.
Pièges courants
Explaining the topic at length before the first round, so the 'before' already contains your framing and there is little left to compare
Skipping the bridge because time is short; two lists without the comparison are just note-taking and the routine loses its purpose
Letting people look at their first set while writing the second, which leads to light edits of the old answers and hides the real shift
Treating the first responses as misconceptions to correct, after which participants play safe in every later round
Dropping the metaphor because it feels awkward; it is often the item that shows a change in understanding most clearly
Variantes
Remote: use a shared board with one frame per person and hide the first set until the second is written. Large audiences: individual writing, then the bridge in pairs with neighbours and a few voices by microphone or poll. Multi-day course: do the first set on day one and the second at the end, with the bridge as closing reflection. Team version: cluster the 'after' questions on a wall to plan the next learning step.
Contextes d'utilisation
Quand l'utiliser
A session contains a substantial input and you want participants to notice how it changed their view, not just whether they liked it
People arrive with firm opinions on the topic, and you want those on paper before the input challenges them
A training has to show learning progress to participants or sponsors without running a test
The group has some prior knowledge of the topic, so the first round produces real material to compare against
You need a reflection frame that takes a few minutes at each end of a session and no preparation
Quand ne pas l'utiliser
Participants know nothing about the topic; the first round then yields guesses, so start with See, Think, Wonder or a short orientation instead
There is no learning experience between the two rounds; without new input the comparison is empty, and a single reflection such as What, So What, Now What fits better
You only have time at the end of the session; use I Used to Think, But Now I Think, which reconstructs the before from memory
The aim is a decision or an action plan; this routine produces insight about one's own thinking, not agreements
Méthodes associées
Questions fréquemment posées
What is 3-2-1 Bridge?▾
3-2-1 Bridge is a thinking routine from Project Zero at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. Participants write three thoughts, two questions and one metaphor about a topic before a learning experience, write a fresh set afterwards, and then explain how the two sets connect. The comparison, called the bridge, makes visible how their understanding has moved.
What do the 3, 2 and 1 stand for?▾
Three words or thoughts that come to mind about the topic, two questions the person has, and one metaphor or simile that captures how they currently see it. The same three items are written twice, once before and once after the input.
How long does 3-2-1 Bridge take?▾
The published routine states no fixed duration. In workshop practice, plan about three to five minutes for each round of writing and five to ten minutes for the bridge, so ten to twenty minutes in total, split between the start and the end of a session.
Does it work with adults in a business setting?▾
Yes. The routine was designed for classrooms, but the mechanics carry over to trainings, leadership programmes and briefings with expert input. Adults sometimes resist the metaphor, so offer an example and keep it light.
What makes a good bridge statement?▾
A good bridge names a specific change and its cause, for example which idea was replaced, which question was answered, or why the metaphor no longer fits. Statements such as 'I learned a lot' are too general. Asking 'what made you change that?' in the pair conversation usually gets to the specific point.
Planifiez votre prochain atelier avec l'IA
Workshop Weaver vous aide à combiner des méthodes comme 3-2-1 Bridge en un agenda complet et minuté en quelques minutes.
Essayer gratuitementMethod descriptions on Workshop Weaver are original content written by our team, based on established facilitation practices. This method was inspired by work from Project Zero, Harvard Graduate School of Education.